Council of Europe to vote tomorrow on a controversial recommendation on surrogacy

The controversies around Council of Europe’s surrogacy report drafted by discussed rapporteur De Sutter (Belgium) are not finished yet.

On the 21st September, the Council of Europe’s Social Affairs and Health Committee rejected De Sutter’s report for the second time. At the same time, the Committee approved a draft recommendation to the Committee of Ministers to draw up “European guidelines to safeguard children’s rights in relation to surrogacy arrangements“.

The adopted draft recommendation, based on the rejected report prepared by Petra de Sutter also says that the Committee of Ministers should collaborate with the Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH) on private international law issues surrounding the status of children, including problems arising in relation to legal parentage resulting from international surrogacy agreements, with a view to ensuring that the views of the Council of Europe (including those of PACE and the European Court of Human Rights) are “heard and taken into account in any multilateral instrument that may result from the work of the HCCH”. (PACE website)

This draft recommendation will have to be approved by the same Committee and the whole Assembly of the Council of Europe tomorrow.

Many negative reactions have already been registered:

“We ask to reject that recommendation and to defend the rights of women, in particular the most vulnerable. The first item in this recommendation is to “consider the desirability and feasibility of drawing up European guidelines to safeguard children’s rights in relation to surrogacy arrangements”. Such an item is not acceptable. Recommending guidelines that organize for the consequences of surrogacy arrangements, instead of requiring first the abolition of surrogacy, is akin to accepting surrogacy as an existing fact.”

  • FAFCE  (Federation of Catholic Family Association in Europe) President, Antoine Renard says:

We don’t think that the Members of the Assembly will assume a coward attitude, but we trust they will take a strong stand against the practice of surrogacy, recommending all Member States to ban it.” In fact, the current text is really ambiguous, and remains very vague on how to really protect children’s rights and how to fight surrogacy. If children’s rights need to be safeguarded in relation to surrogacy arrangements, as the draft recommendation currently states, why not recommending to stop this kind of arrangements?

  •  ECPM (European Christian Political Movement) member and Member of the Moldovan Parliament Valeriu Ghiletchi:

“I was glad to see MPs from different European countries, including from various parties, united in this battle to defend moral values and human dignity. It is unacceptable to exploit women renting their reproductive organs as they bear children in order. It is even worse to turn children into merchandise and send them immediately after birth to those who paid for the service contract surrogate. Children need a real mother, not a surrogate mother. Today’s victory is a strong ray of light in a world increasingly comprised of darkness!”

In Italy also fifty Italian lesbian and activist women signed a document against surrogacy. It is one of the first document proposed by the LGBT community “to refuse the commercialisation of women’s body.”  The promoters say the document should not be considered as prohibitionist, but against the possibility of buying and selling human beings.

112 comments

  1. Pingback: Consiliul Europei a spus definitiv: „NU traficului de maternitate”! – Stiri Crestine.ro

  2. Pingback: prices of cialis

  3. Pingback: cialis 20 mg price

  4. Pingback: Pfizer viagra canada

  5. Pingback: pills erectile dysfunction

  6. Pingback: pills for erection

  7. Pingback: ed pills otc

  8. Pingback: sale cialis

  9. Pingback: online pharmacy

  10. Pingback: generic cialis online

  11. Pingback: generic vardenafil online

  12. Pingback: casino games

  13. Pingback: online casino real money paypal

  14. Pingback: cheapest generic viagra

  15. Pingback: live casino slots online

  16. Pingback: san manuel casino online

  17. Pingback: payday loans online

  18. Pingback: online payday loans

  19. Pingback: online payday loans

  20. Pingback: viagra cost

  21. Pingback: 5 mg cialis

  22. Pingback: crown europe online casino

  23. Pingback: gambling casino online

  24. Pingback: online gambling

  25. Pingback: golden nugget online casino

  26. Pingback: top 50 online casinos

  27. Pingback: cialis buy

  28. Pingback: cialis generic

  29. Pingback: generic cialis

  30. Pingback: cialis buy

  31. Pingback: casino games

  32. Pingback: online casino real money us

  33. Pingback: casino world

  34. Pingback: online viagra prescription

  35. Pingback: discount viagra

  36. Pingback: viagra price

  37. Pingback: tadalafil 20

  38. Pingback: order viagra

  39. Pingback: generic cialis at walmart

  40. Pingback: viagra canada

  41. Pingback: viagra substitute

  42. Pingback: buy furosemide 100mg

  43. Pingback: viagra prices

  44. Pingback: cheap generic viagra

  45. Pingback: cialis 20 mg

  46. Pingback: buy viagra in delhi

  47. Pingback: cialis etkileri

  48. Pingback: augmentin 500/125mg pharmacy

  49. Pingback: pfizer viagra cost

  50. Pingback: cialis 20mg uk

  51. Pingback: cialis info

  52. Pingback: cheap catapres 100mcg

  53. Pingback: ceclor 500mg pills

  54. Pingback: how to purchase ceftin

  55. Pingback: celebrex 100 mg without a doctor prescription

  56. Pingback: celexa tablets

  57. Pingback: where to buy cephalexin

  58. Pingback: cipro pharmacy

  59. Pingback: claritin 10mg without a doctor prescription

  60. Pingback: sugarhouse casino online

  61. Pingback: hollywood casino online

  62. Pingback: online casino real money

  63. Pingback: casino online real money

  64. Pingback: play for real online casino games

  65. Pingback: slot machine

  66. Pingback: slot machines

  67. Pingback: slot machines

  68. Pingback: play for real online casino games

  69. Pingback: real money casino games

  70. Pingback: geico car insurance quotes official site

  71. Pingback: insurance car companies

  72. Pingback: cheap insurance car

  73. Pingback: cheap ed pills

  74. Pingback: nationwide car insurance quotes

  75. Pingback: viagra at boots

  76. Pingback: insurance auto

  77. Pingback: extremely cheap car insurance quotes

  78. Pingback: car insurance quotes

  79. Pingback: car insurance quotes online

  80. Pingback: average cost of car insurance quotes

  81. Pingback: check into cash

  82. Pingback: payday loans no credit check

  83. Pingback: buy viagra online canadian

  84. Pingback: installment loans no credit check

  85. Pingback: quick loans in pa

  86. Pingback: bad credit loans las vegas

  87. Pingback: online payday loans florida

  88. Pingback: personal loans georgia

  89. Pingback: cbd oil benefits 2016 usa

  90. Pingback: straight hemp cbd oil

  91. Pingback: viagra 100mg price usa

  92. Pingback: buy real viagra no prescription

  93. Pingback: viagra insurance coverage

  94. Pingback: buy generic viagra canada online

  95. Pingback: best cbd oil for cancer treatment

  96. Pingback: can cbd oil affect drug test

  97. Pingback: viagra 100mg price usa

  98. Pingback: buy cbd oil online

  99. Pingback: Buy viagra now online

  100. Pingback: write essay for me

  101. Pingback: buy viagra without prescription uk

  102. Pingback: research paper writer free

  103. Pingback: viagra cream price

  104. Pingback: essay writing service canada

  105. Pingback: dissertation online

  106. Pingback: writing college essay

  107. Pingback: viagra generic without prescription

  108. Pingback: college application essay writing service

  109. Pingback: free online paper writer

  110. Pingback: online essay writing service review

  111. Pingback: write college essay

  112. Pingback: cleocin 300 mg tablets