In the past weeks, following the tragic events in Paris, suddenly the issue of “foreign fighters” has begun to pop-up in every newspaper and in mass media. In the last few days, many important national and European politicians have repeatedly stated that “foreign fighters” are an open issue for the security of the whole Europe. In this vortex of news and press releases, the same “foreign fighters” word has never been translated in other languages, a clear symptom of how this topic is hot in the current debate. But beyond the label, the main question still remains: why do we speak about “foreign fighters”, and who are they?
“Foreign” fighters. Are we sure?
It is quite common for the human psychology to assume that an episode or a fact is true if we receive many unanimous and concurrent inputs. Mass media tends to take advantage of this phenomenon by repeating the same headlines which in turn causes the reader to view the information as unfalsifiable. Therefore, today all the media are bombarding the public with news about the “foreign fighters”. But are we sure that they are “foreign”? According to many sources, the main issue is that these fighters are coming in our countries from abroad: therefore they are considered foreigners. But the real issue is different: many times the “foreign fighters” are not “foreign” at all, but they have the citizenships, habits, accents, education and linguistic knowledge identical to many British, Italian, French or Belgian youngsters. Their passports have been issued by European authorities, and many of them were born in European hospitals and have spent the years of their childhood in European cities.
So why are they considered “foreign” fighters? They are called “foreign” because they are fighting in countries (like Syria or Iraq) which are geographically far from ours; but if we consider them from the social or juridical point of view, many of them are not “foreign” at all, they belong to our society in the same way as we belong.
This should be clear when we read articles or we listen to some news dealing with this issue: the majority of the European foreign fighters which are fighting in Syria and Iraq are European citizens. This element should not be overlooked; it means that when these people come back to our countries, they are very difficult to spot or track by police authorities, because, basically, they look absolutely identical to the rest of the population.
The “global call” for foreign fighters: an awkward assessment
Today the issue of the “foreign fighters” is mainly related to the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS) and the “volunteers” who are currently serving under ISIS’ flag. It is no secret that the Caliphate’s units are also composed of a substantial amount of foreign people: but the current situation is slightly different from other conflicts. In the course of history, many wars have attracted foreign fighters: during the XX century, for instance, one of the most famous cases was the Spanish Civil War (1936-1939), which attracted important politicians, political dissidents and intellectuals. They were grouped in the famous “International brigade”; on a smaller scale, even Franco’s positions attracted many foreign volunteers. In recent times the Soviet-Afghan war (1979-1989) or the conflicts in the Balkans during the 90s have attracted – again – many foreign people, who decided to join the ranks of the Afghan rebels or one of the factions active in former Jugoslavia. But the current war in Syria and Iraq has shown the globalised reach (a “global call”) for the foreign fighters; currently between 10.000 and 15.000 volunteers are fighting in the Middle East, and their origins are incredibly diverse. From the alleged case of two Japanese ISIS militants to the nearly 3000 Tunisians fighters, it is no secret that the civil war in Syria and Iraq is now a small but globalised conflict. Thousands of foreign fighters are coming from all over the world, which includes not only Arab countries, such as Tunisia or Saudi Arabia, but also the US, Canada, Australia and even China; in Europe the situation is more complicated (click here for the map).
In the “top list” of ISIS (human) contributors there are the UK and France, obviously, the large community of Muslim people in these countries is a perfect place to recruit foreign fighters, even if many of them, as we know, were born and raised in the streets of London or Paris. Other countries are also included in this list, as Germany or Sweden (approx. 400 people), while others contribute fewer fighters, like Spain (approx. 100), Italy (approx. 50) or Ireland (approx. 25). However, such numbers are an approximation because the state prefers not to (can they?) make the “official” number of their own foreign fighters public. It is worth noting a second element, despite the fact that foreign fighters are mainly fighting in ISIS units, it does not mean that they are all Muslims. Many foreign fighters are joining ISIS’ ranks for money, ideological (which is different from religious) reasons or to eventually look for tough “adventures”. In this case religion plays a very peculiar role, as many Muslims authorities in both Western and Eastern countries are criticising ISIS as a “not-Muslim” organisation. Not every ISIS member can be considered a Muslim and it is being Muslim does not make one sympathise with the organisation. Equating ISIS with Islam is a technique often used in mass media for political reasons, such as raising Islamophobia, however it is clearly nothing more than a logical fallacy.
Therefore being Muslim is not a pre-requisite to be an ISIS “volunteer”, which falsifies the equation that ISIS equals foreign fighters which equals, Islam is wrong, despite it being quoted as such in the mass media, and mainly for political calculations or electoral purposes.
Foreign fighters, domestic threats
The main threat posed by “foreign fighters” lies in them being much more local than “foreign”. While those people are actively putting their lives in danger fighting in distant countries such as Syria and Iraq, they can also be a major threat to Western society. Of course, even if we try to categorise these people along national lines (the Italian fighters, the British, the French…) it is impossible to forecast what every single person will do. From a national security point of view, it would be more advantageous to consider the dangerous goals that some (and usually isolated) foreign fighters could pursue.
A “softer” course of action could be the recruitment of other “volunteers” to fight abroad, through the use of human contacts (proselitism one-by-one or using some networks, as associations or NGOs) or on the web by using special websites and/or chat lines. A more violent course of action could involve extreme cases of terrorism, as was the case during the attack on Charlie Hebdo in Paris. The intensity and the scale of this attack shocked the whole of Europe and has sparked interest in the role of foreign fighters in our societies. However, as we know, the threat related to foreign fighters is not only limited to violent and overt action. The recruitment of new followers, assisting other foreign fighters (logistics, “safe houses”, information, weapons…) and the spread of radical opinions (by physical means or using the web) are pressing threats that cannot be overlooked anymore.
So, it is quite clear to understand why foreign fighters are a relevant domestic threat: future attacks, as the last slaughter in Paris, cannot be completely ruled out in our societies. This threat is a serious challenge for European countries, but the answer cannot be only limited to police actions and a tighter surveillance. Eventually, it is wrong to identify the issue of the foreign fighters just as a military or a law and order problem. We should try to understand more deeply the reasons that drive many young people to leave their families and pour into the tough conflict in the Middle East, remembering that many of these warriors can easily be (or maybe have been) our citizens and, sometimes, our neighbours or even colleagues.
Further readings:
Pingback: Italy to ban “Foreign Fighters” | The European Post
Pingback: If Libya fails it could be Somalia on the Mediterranean | The European Post
Pingback: Islamic State ‘planning to use Libya as gateway to Europe’ | The European Post
Pingback: Number of Foreign Fighters Per Capita (Per Million People) | The European Post
Pingback: French PM warns that 10,000 Europeans may join ISIS | The European Post
Pingback: Turkey already deported 1,154 foreign fighters so far | The European Post
Pingback: Where do the foreign fighters come from? | The European Post
Pingback: 70 women left Germany to join ISIS | The European Post
Pingback: Black islamic flags already waiving in Europe | The European Post
Pingback: European foreign ministers adopt new legal standards for tackling “foreign terrorist fighters” | The European Post
Pingback: Where do the foreign fighters come from? | The European Post
Pingback: URL
Pingback: Look at this Trendy Outfits
Pingback: Bdsm chat
Pingback: iraqi coehuman
Pingback: www.graphxdiva.com
Pingback: pendaftaran cpns 2018-2019 jember
Pingback: Togel Online
Pingback: Software gigi
Pingback: loker di indonesia
Pingback: college of law1
Pingback: corporate uniform supplier qatar
Pingback: best barbershops in birmingham al
Pingback: assistência informática
Pingback: Diyala Engineering4
Pingback: managed cloud
Pingback: gifts for photographers
Pingback: Shemale Escorts in New York City
Pingback: assistência informática
Pingback: primary 1 maths
Pingback: http://www.sendvaluegiftbaskets.com
Pingback: see this site
Pingback: find a niche market
Pingback: ibanez gsr205sm review
Pingback: visit here
Pingback: dent training
Pingback: loker2018.com
Pingback: Hack Website
Pingback: Aplikasi dental clinic
Pingback: vidtube to mp3
Pingback: freelance developer
Pingback: Zimano
Pingback: go to these guys
Pingback: arab Ceohuman
Pingback: Viagra vs cialis
Pingback: Viagra generika
Pingback: Cialis prices
Pingback: Viagra lowest price
Pingback: Buy generic cialis
Pingback: Viagra or cialis
Pingback: Viagra 20 mg best price
Pingback: Buy generic cialis
Pingback: Cialis prices
Pingback: Cialis prices
Pingback: Cialis online
Pingback: essayforme
Pingback: Cialis 5 mg
Pingback: Generic cialis
Pingback: Ambika Ahuja Jaipur Escorts
Pingback: NEHA TYAGI MODEL JAIPUR ESCORTS
Pingback: JAIPUR ESCORTS ALIYA SINHA
Pingback: BANGALORE COMPANION ESCORTS
Pingback: Dhruvi Jaipur Escorts
Pingback: JAIPUR ESCORTS MODEL DRISHYA
Pingback: Heena Khan Bangalore Escorts
Pingback: Jiya Malik High Profile Jaipur Escorts Model
Pingback: FUN WITH JAIPUR ESCORTS PUJA KAUR
Pingback: XXX BANGALORE ESCORTS ROZLYN MODEL
Pingback: XXX PORN SAPNA CHAUDHARY ESCORTS IN BANGALORE
Pingback: Enjoy With Jaipur Escorts Tanisha Walia
Pingback: Selly Arora Independent Bangalore Escorts
Pingback: RUBEENA RUSSIAN BANGALORE ESCORTS
Pingback: SRUTHI PATHAK MODEL ESCORTS IN BANGALORE
Pingback: Bristy Roy Independent Bangalore Escorts
Pingback: Bangalore Escorts Sneha Despandey
Pingback: XXX PORN MODEL HONEY PREET Escorts in Bangalore
Pingback: Radhika Apte Model Escort in Bangalore
Pingback: Goa Escorts Eva J Law
Pingback: Kolkata Escorts Services Fiza Khan
Pingback: Ruby Sen Kolkata Independent Escorts Services
Pingback: Diana Diaz Goa Independent Escorts Services
Pingback: Diksha Arya Independent Escorts Services in Kolkata
Pingback: Devika Kakkar Goa Escorts Services
Pingback: Rebecca Desuza Goa Independent Escorts Services
Pingback: Yamini Mittal Independent Escorts Services in Goa
Pingback: Simmi Mittal Kolkata Escorts Services
Pingback: Kolkata Escorts Services Ragini Mehta
Pingback: Navya Sharma Independent Kolkata Escorts Services
Pingback: Elisha Roy Goa Independent Escorts Services
Pingback: Alisha Oberoi Independent Escorts in Kolkata
Pingback: Divya Arora Goa Independent Escorts Services
Pingback: Simran Batra Independent Escorts in Kolkata
Pingback: Ashna Ahuja Escorts Services in Kolkata
Pingback: Sofia Desai Escorts Services in Goa
Pingback: Goa Escorts Services Drishti Goyal
Pingback: Mayra Khan Escorts Services in Kolkata
Pingback: Sruthi Pathak Escorts in Bangalore
Pingback: Ambika Ahuja Jaipur Escorts Services
Pingback: freshamateurs221
Pingback: europeanpost.co486
Pingback: europeanpost.co169
Pingback: comment83
Pingback: comment993
Pingback: comment500
Pingback: comment253
Pingback: comment887
Pingback: comment453
Pingback: comment307
Pingback: comment474
Pingback: comment239
Pingback: comment627
Pingback: comment337
Pingback: comment567
Pingback: comment300
Pingback: comment822
Pingback: comment512
Pingback: comment533
Pingback: comment629
Pingback: comment115
Pingback: comment469
Pingback: comment909
Pingback: comment414
Pingback: comment349
Pingback: Sruthi Pathak Bangalore Female Escorts
Pingback: latestvideo sirius476 abdu23na4577 abdu23na7
Pingback: sirius latest movs494 abdu23na2848 abdu23na24
Pingback: download on mobile441 afeu23na7825 abdu23na97
Pingback: tubela.net143 afeu23na7533 abdu23na37
Pingback: sfgjidfgn583 afeu23na8139 abdu23na69
Pingback: 634zPgmZcXU
Pingback: hdmobilesex.me
Pingback: buy cialis without a doctor's prescription
Pingback: Sruthi Pathak Bangalore Escorts Services
Pingback: Trully Independent Bangalore Escorts Services
Pingback: tedwap.me
Pingback: click here
Pingback: Fiza Khan Kolkata Independent Call Girls Services
Pingback: Cialis 20mg
Pingback: Ruchika Roy Kolkata Escorts Call Girls Services
Pingback: Branding
Pingback: Fiza Khan Kolkata Independent Escorts Call Girls Services
Pingback: Fiza Khan Kolkata Call Girls Escorts Services
Pingback: Diksha Arya Kolkata Escorts Call Girls Services
Pingback: Diksha Arya Kolkata Independent Escorts Call Girls Services
Pingback: cialis online without prescriptio
Pingback: website
Pingback: example.org.17
Pingback: free bitcoin cash
Pingback: northwest pharmacy canada
Pingback: northwestpharmacy
Pingback: Viagra tablets australia
Pingback: Viagra 5mg prix
Pingback: Viagra 5mg
Pingback: Buy generic viagra
Pingback: Viagra great britain
Pingback: Generic for viagra
Pingback: Cialis prices
Pingback: Buy cialis online
Pingback: buy tadalafil pills
Pingback: Cheap
Pingback: Nidika Offer Call Girls in Bangalore
Pingback: Purchasing viagra on the internet
Pingback: buy viagra usa
Pingback: buy generic viagra pills
Pingback: levitra vs viagra ingredients
Pingback: levitra generic 5mg
Pingback: generic levitra
Pingback: low cost levitra
Pingback: levitra coupons
Pingback: Generic viagra
Pingback: buy generic viagra online
Pingback: Viagra 20 mg best price
Pingback: Viagra 20mg
Pingback: buy levitra generic
Pingback: sildenafil 100mg
Pingback: viagra on line
Pingback: viagra without doctor prescription
Pingback: viagra generic
Pingback: canada pharmacy
Pingback: international pharmacy
Pingback: canadian pharmacies online
Pingback: drugstore online
Pingback: canada pharmacy
Pingback: tadalafil
Pingback: tadalafil 20mg
Pingback: cheap cialis
Pingback: tadalafil 20 mg
Pingback: cialis generic
Pingback: generic cialis tadalafil
Pingback: cialis prices
Pingback: pharmacy
Pingback: canadian pharmaceuticals online
Pingback: pharmacy
Pingback: international pharmacy
Pingback: canadian pharmacies
Pingback: canadian pharmacies online
Pingback: canadian online pharmacies
Pingback: viagra
Pingback: sildenafil 100mg
Pingback: we-b-tv.com
Pingback: hs;br
Pingback: tureckie_serialy_na_russkom_jazyke
Pingback: 00-tv.com
Pingback: æóêè+2+ñåðèÿ
Pingback: Ñìîòðåòü âñå ñåðèè ïîäðÿä
Pingback: watch
Pingback: HD-720
Pingback: guardians+of+the+galaxy+2
Pingback: my id is gangnam beauty
Pingback: 2020
Pingback: kpop+star+season+6+ep+9
Pingback: Video
Pingback: +1+
Pingback: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Pingback: Hyderabad Escorts Call Girls Services
Pingback: Pune Escorts Services Call Girls
Pingback: movies
Pingback: movies online
Pingback: karan johar
Pingback: Top Movies
Pingback: Movies1
Pingback: 11 10 2019
Pingback: Bangalore Cheap Escorts Sevices
Pingback: smotretonline2015.ru
Pingback: Serial smotret
Pingback: kinokrad
Pingback: kinokrad 2020
Pingback: ñïèñîê íîâûõ ôèëüìîâ
Pingback: Watch TV Shows
Pingback: amoxicillin 875 mg
Pingback: casino
Pingback: Kinokrad 2019 Kinokrad Hd
Pingback: filmy-kinokrad
Pingback: kinokrad-2019
Pingback: filmy-2019-kinokrad
Pingback: serial
Pingback: cerialest.ru
Pingback: dorama hdrezka
Pingback: movies hdrezka
Pingback: HDrezka
Pingback: kinosmotretonline
Pingback: LostFilm HD 720
Pingback: trustedmdstorefy.com
Pingback: bofilm ñåðèàë
Pingback: bofilm
Pingback: 1 seriya
Pingback: Êîíñóëüòàöèÿ ïñèõîëîãà
Pingback: topedstoreusa.com