The European Parliament elections destabilised Italy’s coalition government, by weakening the Five Star Movement and strengthening the League. The EU should avoid giving populists an excuse to lash out, or it may find itself with an even more eurosceptic government in Rome.
The European Parliament elections last month were a key test for Rome’s coalition government between Matteo Salvini’s right-wing, anti-immigration League and the populist Five Star Movement (5S). The result was a profound shift in the country’s political landscape: the League doubled its share of the vote compared to the March 2018 general election to 34 per cent. In contrast, 5S lost half of its votes, with its support halving to 17 per cent. The centre-left Democratic Party made up for some of the ground lost in 2018, securing just over 20 per cent. Meanwhile, Silvio Berlusconi’s Forza Italia looks like a spent force, with less than 10 per cent of the vote. The two parties in the governing coalition maintained their combined votes share, but the power within has shifted strongly to the League.
For now, the coalition just about endures. A collapse now would mean voting in the middle of the summer holidays, which would reduce turnout, and Salvini is wary of pulling the plug, as the public might consider him to be throwing the country into crisis out of personal ambition. Nor would the government’s fall necessarily lead to snap elections that the League might win. Italy’s president would first gauge whether a new majority was possible. The numbers in parliament are such that the centre-left opposition and the 5S could form a coalition. Although they currently say they would prefer elections, there is a chance both the 5S and the centre-left could change their mind if the government falls and they are faced with a high likelihood of defeat. The political distance between the two parties has shrunk: the Democratic Party has shifted to the left after Matteo Renzi stood down as leader. Meanwhile, parts of the 5S have always looked favourably on an alliance with the left, and an agreement with the Democratic Party may seem even more appealing following their bruising experience of governing with the League.
The possibility of a 5S-Democratic Party coalition, even if unlikely, explains Salvini’s apparent reticence to try to capitalise on his strong position. Additionally, Salvini would prefer to steer clear of an alliance with Berlusconi, and a League-led coalition may not win a majority without Forza Italia’s votes. Therefore, Salvini stated he will try to continue governing with the 5S, on condition that they stop stalling on the League’s key priorities: the so-called flat-tax, greater autonomy for certain northern Italian regions and the construction of the Lyon-Turin high-speed railway. If the 5S agrees to the League’s demands, Salvini will be able to secure victories while further weakening his coalition partner. On the other hand, if the 5S refuse to agree to his policies, Salvini would be able to end the coalition, avoiding the accusation that he brought down the government out of personal ambition.

The 5S is torn: if it continues to govern, it will risk losing further support. But if it breaks the coalition, it would probably have to face early elections, in which it would face heavy losses. Additionally, most of 5S’s prominent lawmakers, including leader and deputy prime minister, Luigi Di Maio, would be unable to stand again, as the party imposes a two-term limit on its representatives.
Italy finds itself politically isolated, in a fragile economic condition and in the middle of a new struggle over its budgetary plans with the European Commission.
At the same time, Italy finds itself politically isolated, in a fragile economic condition and in the middle of a new struggle over its budgetary plans with the European Commission. The outgoing Commission has just issued its report recommending an ‘excessive deficit procedure’ (EDP). In December last year, Rome narrowly avoided an EDP, after the government watered down and deferred its expensive electoral promises of tax cuts and spending increases. For its part, the Commission accepted Rome’s widely optimistic forecast of 1.5 per cent growth in 2019.
However, the deal proved short lived, as the Italian economy has slowed together with the European economy and is projected to grow at just 0.1 per cent of GDP in 2019. Moreover, the costs of servicing Italy’s public debt have increased as markets are losing confidence in the Italian government. As a result, the Commission predicts that the budget deficit for this year will increase to 2.5 per cent of GDP, and public debt to 133.7 per cent. This has put Italy in serious breach of its debt reduction target. Moreover, Italy’s finances are set to worsen further in 2020. With current policies, the Commission sees the budget deficit rising to 3.5 per cent, with debt rising to 135 per cent of GDP.
It is now up to member-states to decide whether to follow the Commission’s recommendation to open the EDP against Italy. The procedure has several phases, but could eventually result in a fine of up to 0.2 per cent of GDP. The EU has tried to avoid giving Rome an excuse to lash out, with economy Commissioner Pierre Moscovici saying that he was open to further discussions. But Rome is unlikely to back down: while economics minister Giovanni Tria has sought to reassure the EU that Rome is planning a programme of spending cuts and revenue boosting measures, Salvini has repeated calls for a ‘fiscal shock’ and for Italy to ignore the eurozone’s 3 per cent budget deficit limit.
The Commission’s criticism of Italy presents a golden opportunity for Italian eurosceptics to rail against ‘Brussels’. Salvini and the 5S will exploit the complicated and poorly understood nature of the EU’s fiscal rules to argue that the Commission has singled out Italy for criticism, and that France (which is set to run a deficit above 3 per cent in 2019) has been able to avoid the procedure. The EU’s patchy insistence on adherence to rules plays into the populists’ argument that Italy’s fiscal policy is constrained by Brussels – rather than being largely the result of Italy’s own economic weakness.
The launch of an EDP may embolden Salvini to precipitate the breakup of the coalition, avoiding the need to draw up a budget with the 5S, and further benefitting from eurosceptic sentiment. The 5S would then have to form a coalition with the Democratic Party and bear responsibility for putting together the 2020 budget, or face losses in new elections. In an election campaign, an EDP would make it harder for pro-Europeans to argue their case. If the European Parliament election results were replicated in a new general election, the outcome would be a right-wing coalition made up by the League and the smaller right-wing nationalist Brothers of Italy, possibly including Berlusconi’s Forza Italia. A coalition between the 5S and the Democratic Party is far less likely, as it would be very difficult for the two to agree to a formal pre-electoral alliance – improving the League and its allies’ chances of victory.
At the same time, an EDP will probably fail to force Italy to alter its spending plans. The Commission seeks an annual fiscal retrenchment of 0.6 per cent of GDP until the structural deficit is in balance. While no Italian government would be willing to commit to, or be able to implement such fiscal tightening given the current political climate and Italy’s economic weakness, any government will be constrained by market pressure anyway. Last year, the rising cost of financing Italy’s debt drove the League and the 5S to water down their electoral promises. The markets would react in a similar way to a splurge in next year’s budget, which should prevent any government from going too far. The priority of any government in the 2020 budget will be finding resources to offset (at least in part) €23 billion of highly unpopular VAT increases, legislated in the 2019 budget. The current government may be the most constrained of any possible coalition in its ability to raise revenue or cut spending: the League opposes higher taxes, while the 5S do not want to roll back the party’s flagship policy, a ‘citizens’ income’ which provides higher welfare payments for poor people, and which was launched in March. A Five Star – Democratic Party coalition could have more leeway to raise revenue, perhaps through higher taxes on high earners.
A right-wing coalition led by the League would take a more confrontational stance towards the EU than the current government over migration and foreign policy, and would seek to pick more fights with France. But it would probably be more fiscally conservative than the current government. It is easy to overestimate pressure for fiscal expansion within the League’s electorate, whose main concerns are migration, and law and order issues.
Salvini’s proposal for a ‘flat tax’ should not be taken literally, but rather as a provocation, and a symbol for lowering taxes. It would be quite possible for Salvini to claim victory with minimal moves and vague plans to bring down higher rates in following years. Moreover, the League would cut – or eliminate – 5S’s citizen’s income. A more concerning development is the League’s support for ‘mini-Bots’, a form of scrip currency that, if introduced, risks fuelling the perception that Italy is preparing to exit the euro. While Parliament has instructed the government to look into the idea, the plan remains embryonic, and pressure on the League to back off from markets and business constituencies within its own electorate will rise if the plan comes anywhere near fruition.
The pressure from markets means the EU can approach the EDP with pragmatism. It should not simply give in to populists, of course. But instead of trying to push Italy towards a fiscal retrenchment of a magnitude which would be politically difficult for any government, and could be economically damaging, a more promising route would be for the Commission to steer Rome’s spending away from welfare increases and income tax cuts, towards measures that are likelier to boost growth, for example investment in education, one of Italy’s key weakness. This could offer Rome an exit from the corner the government has moved itself into.
If the dispute escalates, Italy may suffer from market turmoil. But the EU would also lose out: eurosceptic sentiment in Italy (and possibly across the EU) would be strengthened, Italy could descend into a serious economic crisis and the fiscal rules would be further discredited as a tool to maintain stability in the eurozone.
Cover pic: Shutterstock.com
Pingback: generic ventolin
Pingback: viagra pills for sale
Pingback: generic cialis online no prescription
Pingback: cheap viagra
Pingback: buy naltrexone
Pingback: generic bimatoprost ophthalmic solution
Pingback: how much viagra should i take the first time?
Pingback: tylenol order
Pingback: buy chloroquine online uk
Pingback: hydroxychloroquine pills
Pingback: buy cialis
Pingback: optional health care viagra abortion
Pingback: careprost bimatoprost
Pingback: cialis prices
Pingback: canadian generic viagra online
Pingback: buy hydroxychloroquine online
Pingback: viagra price per pill
Pingback: Viagra 200mg united states
Pingback: Cialis 60 mg without a doctor prescription
Pingback: Cialis 60mg without prescription
Pingback: Cialis 80 mg usa
Pingback: cialis 20mg
Pingback: payday loans knoxville tn
Pingback: buying viagra online reviews
Pingback: sildenafil 25 mg price
Pingback: where can i get viagra in south africa
Pingback: cbd oil for dogs with seizures dosage
Pingback: buy female viagra pills
Pingback: viagra discount online
Pingback: generic female viagra online
Pingback: my homework now
Pingback: generic viagra sale
Pingback: canadian pharmacies viagra
Pingback: periactin 4 mg otc
Pingback: order pulmicort 200 mcg
Pingback: vantin australia
Pingback: fwpidxxe
Pingback: where can i find viagra online
Pingback: wat is viagra voor vrouwen
Pingback: what does ivermectin during pregnancy
Pingback: glipizide cost
Pingback: isosorbide tablet
Pingback: loperamide uk
Pingback: cialis
Pingback: liquid cialis
Pingback: viagra cheap
Pingback: propranolol 40mg price
Pingback: essay writing service uk
Pingback: imagine you are writing a research paper on margaret
Pingback: pay to write my essay
Pingback: help me start an essay on problem solving
Pingback: course impact essay business ethics and social responsibility
Pingback: lamotrigine online
Pingback: terbinafine purchase
Pingback: amoxicillin 500 mg generic
Pingback: atorvastatin price
Pingback: furosemide without prescription us
Pingback: cost of zithromax
Pingback: stromectol ebay
Pingback: combivent respimat instructions
Pingback: gemfibrozil 300mg tablets
Pingback: clotrimazole 10g pharmacy
Pingback: clomid statistics
Pingback: buy dapoxetine 60mg
Pingback: diflucan directions
Pingback: synthroid side affects
Pingback: cheap metoclopramide 10mg
Pingback: propecia sexual dysfunction
Pingback: neurontin espaГ±ol
Pingback: paxil excessive sweating
Pingback: plaquenil anti inflammatory
Pingback: how to Message on tinder without being matched
Pingback: free dating sites for usa
Pingback: Google
Pingback: best cbd gummies for sleep
Pingback: bachelor's degree
Pingback: rechargeable vibrator
Pingback: BUY RUNTZ WEED ONLINE
Pingback: marijuana dispensaries
Pingback: marijuana dispensaries near me
Pingback: b+ mushrooms
Pingback: buy guns online
Pingback: Glock Guns for sale
Pingback: Takeout
Pingback: MILF Porn Land
Pingback: sancaktepe escort
Pingback: pharmacy canada
Pingback: Sig Romeo5
Pingback: Thc Oil Carts
Pingback: Hex Dumbbells
Pingback: whole king crab for sale
Pingback: costco shed
Pingback: افلام سكس محارم
Pingback: software reviewer
Pingback: datenrettung computer
Pingback: their information
Pingback: Yellow Fever
Pingback: penis pump review
Pingback: avcılar escort
Pingback: CANADA PHARMACY CANADA PHARMACY CANADA PHARMACY
Pingback: Buy Peruvian Cocaine Online
Pingback: happyluke ฟรี300
Pingback: toys for men
Pingback: cleaning sex toys
Pingback: istanbul escort
Pingback: www.canadianpharmacyking.com
Pingback: best prostate massager
Pingback: Restaurants Nanaimo
Pingback: best prostate vibrator
Pingback: battery vibrators
Pingback: Oxygen concentrator price in Sri Lanka
Pingback: visit here
Pingback: lottovip สมัคร
Pingback: ground lease
Pingback: lottovip
Pingback: สมัคร ruay
Pingback: best prostate vibrators
Pingback: handjob stroker
Pingback: how to use the most realistic dildo
Pingback: معرفة اسم المتصل
Pingback: French bulldog
Pingback: avrupa yakasi escort
Pingback: 99defi P2P platfrom
Pingback: streamcomplet
Pingback: European vehicle transport
Pingback: film streaming 2021
Pingback: sites para ver filmes
Pingback: ctrlcoin.io
Pingback: Here
Pingback: male masturbators
Pingback: sex facts
Pingback: best way to masturbate
Pingback: 1xbit
Pingback: penis pump
Pingback: most realistic male masturbator
Pingback: best in ottawa
Pingback: yashodham high school goregaon east
Pingback: 안전놀이터
Pingback: kimber micro 9 for sale
Pingback: 머니상
Pingback: generic viagra 100mg
Pingback: sildenafil viagra
Pingback: vasha kniga
Pingback: Murchison Falls Waterfall
Pingback: viagra otc
Pingback: Kingpen
Pingback: cialis australia
Pingback: how much is a cialis pill
Pingback: Pitbull puppies for sale near me
Pingback: WHERE TO BUY MESCALINE
Pingback: Meadowhead School Academy
Pingback: canadian pharmacy viagra
Pingback: oral sex tips
Pingback: rabbit vibrator
Pingback: viagragates.com
Pingback: بديل تروكولر
Pingback: free download for windows 7
Pingback: laptop app
Pingback: pc games for windows 10
Pingback: full apps download
Pingback: 20 mg cialis for daily use
Pingback: free mp3 juices
Pingback: generic viagra cost
Pingback: sildenafil for sale
Pingback: Freelance communication
Pingback: MacBook Repair Bridgwater
Pingback: amoxicillin online no prescription
Pingback: viagra canada
Pingback: Shipping containers For Sale
Pingback: Amboseli national park
Pingback: propecia in bulk
Pingback: Macbook akku reparatur lachen
Pingback: Uganda adventure safaris
Pingback: buy prednisone tablets
Pingback: best doc johnson sex toys
Pingback: FARMING EQUIPMENT FOR SALE IN KZN
Pingback: shipping containers for sale
Pingback: buy viagra online cheap
Pingback: ارقام بنات
Pingback: Serengeti safari tour
Pingback: aromatherapy shop
Pingback: how to order viagra in canada
Pingback: online sildenafil canada
Pingback: cialis india order
Pingback: ivermectina dosis
Pingback: best viagra pills online
Pingback: sajt
Pingback: stromectol for tooth pain
Pingback: my lowes life
Pingback: eli lilly cialis
Pingback: buy zithramax antibiotic online
Pingback: how to get viagra
Pingback: salbutamol 100micrograms
Pingback: how long are viagra pills good?
Pingback: TRIPLE HEX CARTS
Pingback: best prices generic viagra
Pingback: pdx1 defender 12 gauge
Pingback: savage 110 tactical
Pingback: colors of viagra pills
Pingback: mcx for sale
Pingback: taurus pt92 for sale
Pingback: mossberg mvp patrol
Pingback: generique cialis
Pingback: BUY stiiizy pods
Pingback: magic mushrooms
Pingback: cialis
Pingback: zithromax std treatment
Pingback: buy viagra uk
Pingback: buy weed online usa
Pingback: effect of lisinopril on kidneys
Pingback: juul mint
Pingback: sildenafil coupon
Pingback: beretta semi auto shotgun
Pingback: ROVE CARTRIDGES
Pingback: bohemian coffee table
Pingback: female viagra pills
Pingback: dapoxetine hcl tablets 60 mg prejac
Pingback: weed for sale Alabama
Pingback: bitcoin mining machine for sale in uk
Pingback: sugar gliders for sale
Pingback: Murchison Falls Safari Booking
Pingback: cyberpowerpc infinity x109 gaming pc
Pingback: buy hex dumbbells
Pingback: digital marketing agency
Pingback: G17 GEN 4 MOS STANDARD | 9X19MM
Pingback: Beretta cx4
Pingback: understanding the stock market
Pingback: RissMiner
Pingback: Harlowbury Primary School
Pingback: vertigo
Pingback: bitcoin
Pingback: news
Pingback: azithromycin zithromax over the counter
Pingback: Safari Holidays in Kenya
Pingback: cheap viagra online canadian pharmacy
Pingback: Uganda Safari
Pingback: buy beretta guns online
Pingback: savage grow plus real reviews
Pingback: buy raw garden carts online
Pingback: otc z pack
Pingback: anami sikin benim
Pingback: best male masturbator
Pingback: best male stokers
Pingback: pfizer viagra price
Pingback: Apetamin Syrup 200ml Online
Pingback: Omega Seamaster
Pingback: dank vape carts for sale
Pingback: about canada pharmacy
Pingback: order no prescription viagra
Pingback: raw garden carts
Pingback: viagra without doctor prescription usa
Pingback: natural viagra foods
Pingback: viagra sildenafil
Pingback: MURANG'A UNIVERSITY
Pingback: viagra para mujer
Pingback: happyLuke
Pingback: amoxicilin brand name
Pingback: natural alternatives to viagra
Pingback: online lasix
Pingback: neurontin 100mg cap
Pingback: plaquenil brand
Pingback: prednisone drug costs
Pingback: priligy tablets uk
Pingback: viagra dosage
Pingback: modafinil armodafinil
Pingback: stromectol for sale
Pingback: combivent aerosol
Pingback: zithromax 250 mg
Pingback: viagra foods
Pingback: ivermectin price usa
Pingback: Rent a car Crna Gora
Pingback: zithromax tablet
Pingback: women take viagra
Pingback: call girls
Pingback: bitcoin mining rigs
Pingback: asus-phoenix-geforce-rtx-3060-12gb-v2-for-sale
Pingback: Buy La Kush Cake AUSTRALIA
Pingback: CableFreeTV Tech News
Pingback: Gorilla Trekking Bwindi Impenetrable forest
Pingback: cvs viagra
Pingback: Artvin Gazette
Pingback: happyruck.com
Pingback: bitcoin virtual card
Pingback: virtual card buy
Pingback: viagra no prescription
Pingback: russian gifts
Pingback: paxpod
Pingback: bridlewood pinot noir 2017
Pingback: affiliate marketing millionaire
Pingback: e-cigs for sale in usa
Pingback: ruger firearms for sale
Pingback: generic sildenafil
Pingback: best solar generators for home
Pingback: top rated portable power stations
Pingback: best solar panels for home
Pingback: Boshgaon High SchoolKachugaon, Boshgaon Fv, Kokrajhar - 783350
Pingback: Kiwilearners Door No. 3, Ayshika House, Stillwater Court
Pingback: Patharmora H. S Manikbazar/V, Sonamukhi, Bankura - 722207
Pingback: variant
Pingback: aurora teagarden mysteries til death do us part
Pingback: Phentermine 37.5mg for sale
Pingback: how to use toy kits
Pingback: walther q5 match pro
Pingback: Buy Magic Mushrooms
Pingback: browning bar hells canyon
Pingback: DailyCBD
Pingback: beretta cheetah
Pingback: Tours to Uganda
Pingback: female viagra
Pingback: buy real driving license uk
Pingback: where to buy pentobarbital
Pingback: order gbl online usa
Pingback: disposable ecigs
Pingback: buy kimber guns online
Pingback: sildenafil teva
Pingback: where to buy e-cigarettes online usa
Pingback: payday loans
Pingback: tinder gay dating
Pingback: sildenafil price
Pingback: 17 hmr pistol
Pingback: mossberg 500 jic mariner
Pingback: stromectol online canada
Pingback: iwi tavor 308
Pingback: viagra or cialis
Pingback: sig sauer 10mm
Pingback: best stiiizy pod
Pingback: Psiloybe Cubensis USA
Pingback: food delivery restaurants
Pingback: runger guns for sale europe
Pingback: taurus pt92
Pingback: wasr 2 for sale
Pingback: uca.com.vn
Pingback: Source
Pingback: Buy Caluanie Oxidize Online
Pingback: Spray Painting
Pingback: cigars for sale cheap
Pingback: Независимое бюро информации и аналитики
Pingback: Website design
Pingback: ruger mark iv 22/45 lite
Pingback: rabbit vibrator for women
Pingback: rechargeable vibrators
Pingback: dildo
Pingback: anal training kit
Pingback: винтажные обложки
Pingback: university
Pingback: buy real uk driving licence
Pingback: cervelo r2 on sale
Pingback: BUY LEXOTAN
Pingback: double dildos
Pingback: dual entry vibrator
Pingback: keltec sub 2000
Pingback: viagra over the counter
Pingback: mossberg 930 jm pro for sale
Pingback: cialis sans ordonnance
Pingback: krt disposable
Pingback: Krt disposable vape
Pingback: buy graphics card
Pingback: krt cart
Pingback: gbl wheel cleaner
Pingback: liquid k2 on paper online
Pingback: clit vibrator
Pingback: adam and eve couple sex toys
Pingback: Mount Kilimanjaro hike
Pingback: Bitcoin Wallet
Pingback: - do si dos strain
Pingback: extreme sextoys
Pingback: latisse brow
Pingback: nolvadex sale
Pingback: nolvadex prices
Pingback: Capuchin Monkey For Sale
Pingback: One time credit card
Pingback: junk car removal
Pingback: home refinancing
Pingback: Glock 28
Pingback: Buy Weed Online
Pingback: Colt Python for sale
Pingback: Buy Herbal incense online
Pingback: rechargeable wand massagers
Pingback: fleshlight male pocket stroker
Pingback: best g spot vibrator
Pingback: nude tiktok
Pingback: Desert eagle for sale
Pingback: PlayStation 5 Digital Edition
Pingback: crocoite crystal
Pingback: walther p38 handguns for sale
Pingback: Glock 23 for Sale
Pingback: huge realistic dildos with balls
Pingback: bitcoin credit card
Pingback: Glo carts review
Pingback: pc games for windows 8
Pingback: free download for pc windows
Pingback: free windows app download
Pingback: apps download for windows 8
Pingback: pc games for windows 8
Pingback: free download for pc windows
Pingback: MineFullTrader
Pingback: acho
Pingback: games for pc windows download
Pingback: Colt Python For Sale
Pingback: Herbal incense near me
Pingback: clit massager
Pingback: golden bullet
Pingback: Glock 19
Pingback: Uganda safaris tours
Pingback: www.callgirlsinindia.com/call-girls-pune
Pingback: visit website
Pingback: junk car towing
Pingback: BERETTA 92FS
Pingback: CZ P01
Pingback: Buy Marijuana Online
Pingback: penis girth sleeve
Pingback: windows doktor wolfhausen
Pingback: stock market technical analysis
Pingback: carrefour
Pingback: human resource management assignment help
Pingback: Pain killer pills for sale
Pingback: Google
Pingback: www.proscrapcarremoval.com
Pingback: buy backlinks
Pingback: automatic penis pump
Pingback: thrusting vibrator
Pingback: canadian podcast
Pingback: cryptocurrency wallet with virtual card
Pingback: how to deal with premature ejactulation
Pingback: psychedelic mushroom growing kit amazon
Pingback: Pinball machines for sale
Pingback: Platinum haupia
Pingback: Watermelon haupia
Pingback: Bubble hash
Pingback: Moroccan hash
Pingback: Litto disposable
Pingback: Bubble hash