By: Dr. An Vranckx, Expert Analyst and Adviser, Catalystas Consulting and Aviva Stein, Strategy and Development Consultant, Catalystas Consulting
There is little as confusing in the world of international relations as the issue of moving weapons across borders. Following the aftermath of the 2016 failed coup in Turkey and the subsequent crackdown by the Turkish state on the predominantly Kurdish cities in the south, Dutch NGO Pax released a report regarding Turkey’s expanding military industry. The report recommended that EU countries restrain their arms transfers to Turkey, especially to its land and air forces, until progress towards a political solution with the Kurds could be made. Yet, the Consolidated Report on all EU countries’ exports of military goods and technologies shows that EU country exports to Turkey have actually increased, compared to prior years. Values reached nearly €3 billion worth of export licenses over 2017, with Bulgaria, France, Germany, Italy, and the UK all authorizing millions worth of export licenses for military goods destined to Turkey. The value of military sales from EU countries could have been even higher, if their strategic export control authorities had not refused 16 requests for export licenses to Turkey – a demonstration of caution which would likely have been unheard of prior to the coup attempt.
Though the EU is an economic union, in which all states honor a collectively agreed upon system of approving or denying trade partners and contracts based on a delineated set of 8 criteria, economic decisions do not happen in a vacuum. In the framework of the 2008 EU Common Position on military trade, to which all EU countries adhere, each country’s national export control authorities decide on exports to non-EU countries on a case-by-case basis. In cases such as arms trade deals with Turkey, geopolitical and military influences must also be considered as key factors in these export decisions. As a ‘safe’ ally and member of NATO, Turkey has rarely been denied the opportunity to buy and import military goods or technologies from EU countries. The US influence over NATO also sways these export decisions towards serving foreign policy and military priorities rather than solely economic incentives. However, some EU nations are more cautious than others, with the notable example of the Netherlands’ refusal to sell aircrafts to Turkey – although military naval equipment is still permitted.
Of the criteria spelled out in the EU Common Position, only one leads to a mandatory prohibition on export authorization: the obligation to adhere to embargoes set by international authorities, such as the UN Security Council or the EU’s own Council. This adherence to embargoes has resulted in hindering some arms trade, such as in the demise of a French business opportunity to build two Mistral warships for sale to Russia – a particularly sensitive deal as Russia would have acquired not only the ships, but also the technology needed for producing additional vessels internally. After the Russian annexation of the Crimea, a retaliatory European embargo was put in place to prevent delivering goods to Russia, leading to the retraction of the French-Russian deal, though France renewed the deal with Egypt two years later. The sanctions against Russia have continued, with the EU’s leading members calling for their enforcement until progress has been made towards a peaceful solution between Russia and the Ukraine. However, in October 2018, Italy’s Deputy Prime Minister noted the hypocrisy in disciplining Russia while taking no action against Turkey, which has occupied northern Cyprus since 1974.
No embargo is in place that forces EU countries’ arms export control authorities to effectively ‘blacklist’ Turkey. Once an eager applicant for EU membership, Turkey’s ongoing and recent actions call into question its commitment to peaceful coexistence and human rights. The Turkish state has used military gear procured from EU countries in ways that now embarrass its suppliers. German-designed Leopard tanks have been deployed against the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), the local allies of the Global Coalition Against ISIS in northeastern Syria; a batch of French-sold sorbitol, which can be used as rocket propellant, ended up in the hands of ISIS after vanishing from Turkey in 2015. As a whole, the current state of arms transfers between EU countries and Turkey paints a grim picture for the future of adherence to international norms and respect for human rights. Perhaps it is time to follow the advice of PAX, and support the sale of peace, rather than war.
Cover pic: Shutterstock.com
Pingback: cialis price
Pingback: is cialis generic
Pingback: cheap cialis
Pingback: viagra for sale
Pingback: tadalafil online pharmacy
Pingback: buy ciprofloxacin online
Pingback: albuterol inhaler
Pingback: viagra without a doctor prescription
Pingback: naltrexone price 50mg
Pingback: generic cialis online
Pingback: generic tylenol at walmart
Pingback: chloroquine tablet 500mg
Pingback: uk viagra
Pingback: can i buy chloroquine over the counter
Pingback: ed drugs
Pingback: erectile dysfunction pills
Pingback: male ed pills
Pingback: hydroxychloroquine uk pharmacy
Pingback: buy generic cialis
Pingback: canadian online pharmacy
Pingback: online pharmacy
Pingback: Buy cialis online
Pingback: cialis visa
Pingback: levitra dosage
Pingback: generic levitra
Pingback: cialis 20mg dosage
Pingback: wind creek casino online games
Pingback: sildenafil online
Pingback: hollywood casino online real money
Pingback: best online casinos that payout
Pingback: generic viagra 20mg pills erections
Pingback: buy cialis pills
Pingback: cash payday
Pingback: pay day loans
Pingback: viagra 100mg
Pingback: best real money online casinos
Pingback: best slots to play online
Pingback: estelle
Pingback: empire casino online
Pingback: casino that accept paypal
Pingback: generic cialis
Pingback: order viagra without prescription
Pingback: cialis generic
Pingback: cialis 5 mg
Pingback: generic cialis
Pingback: buy hydroxychloroquine online
Pingback: online casino
Pingback: casino gambling
Pingback: real money online casinos usa
Pingback: casinos
Pingback: viagra prescription
Pingback: viagra online canadian pharmacy
Pingback: viagra dosage
Pingback: buy generic cialis online
Pingback: buy generic cialis online
Pingback: cheap cialis
Pingback: generic cialis online
Pingback: casino games online
Pingback: best online casino real money
Pingback: cheap viagra online
Pingback: sildenafil citrate generic viagra
Pingback: Google
Pingback: free app for windows 8 download
Pingback: health insurance broker
Pingback: Employee health insurance plans
Pingback: health insurance broker
Pingback: aquatherapie für hund
Pingback: russian literature classics
Pingback: most realistic dildos
Pingback: gamdom
Pingback: wolfbet
Pingback: Kenyatta
Pingback: buy cialis online without prescription
Pingback: Loans
Pingback: Mastercard Corporate Credit Card
Pingback: Viagra 100mg prices
Pingback: furnace service colorado springs
Pingback: Cialis 80 mg online pharmacy
Pingback: christian seo
Pingback: computer disposal companies london
Pingback: pubg mobile emülatör hile
Pingback: Teacup Pomeranian Puppies for Sale
Pingback: Puppies for adoption near me
Pingback: THC VAPE JUICE
Pingback: dinh cu canada
Pingback: canadian pharmacy
Pingback: rodos feribot
Pingback: viagra generique livre sous 48h
Pingback: ampicillin 500mg without a prescription
Pingback: mua hat macca o tphcm
Pingback: sweetiehouse
Pingback: cialistodo.com
Pingback: beginner sex toys
Pingback: blogcaodep.com
Pingback: computers
Pingback: cost of augmentin 875/125mg
Pingback: Damiana
Pingback: High Efficiency Irrigation System
Pingback: Gerüstbau
Pingback: havuz market
Pingback: sývý klor
Pingback: sweetiehouse.vn
Pingback: red nose pitbull puppies for sale
Pingback: Shotguns for sale
Pingback: Buy heroin online
Pingback: Pc hilfe wolfhausen
Pingback: Glock 33
Pingback: fluffy kittens for sale
Pingback: FAKE MONEY FOR SALE ONLINE
Pingback: Pomsky Puppies For Sale Near me
Pingback: buy viagra online
Pingback: catapres over the counter
Pingback: sex hard
Pingback: how to buy ceclor
Pingback: where can i buy ceftin 250mg
Pingback: hat hanh nhan an song duoc khong
Pingback: celebrex 200 mg otc
Pingback: thc vape juice
Pingback: celexa otc
Pingback: virtual credit card buy
Pingback: cephalexin 500 mg tablet
Pingback: comfortis without vet prescription
Pingback: cipro 750mg for sale
Pingback: claritin 10 mg over the counter
Pingback: Halkbank İnternet Şubesi Şifre Alma
Pingback: generic viagra
Pingback: best slots to play online
Pingback: ziraat kart şifresi alma
Pingback: golden nugget online casino
Pingback: slot games online
Pingback: Muha Meds Blue Dream 1000mg
Pingback: online casinos
Pingback: wind creek casino online games
Pingback: Naturkosmetik
Pingback: san manuel casino online
Pingback: best online casino for money
Pingback: online casino games for real money
Pingback: generic ed pills
Pingback: real online casino
Pingback: sr22 insurance
Pingback: triple a car insurance
Pingback: HRDF Google Marketing
Pingback: list of car insurance quotes companies
Pingback: Tenuate retard
Pingback: counties viagra is legal
Pingback: 1000mg thc vape juice
Pingback: car insurance quotes in nj
Pingback: Fish scale cocaine
Pingback: nationwide insurance
Pingback: Undergraduate Kenya
Pingback: k2 spray on paper
Pingback: Buy Methadone 10mg online
Pingback: car insurance coverage
Pingback: direct line car insurance quotes
Pingback: american car insurance quotes
Pingback: brazzers
Pingback: payday loans wisconsin
Pingback: leavers t-shirts.
Pingback: installment loans rock hill sc
Pingback: buy viagra online with paypal
Pingback: usa pharmacy
Pingback: payday
Pingback: small payday loans for bad credit
Pingback: personal loans companies
Pingback: Fda approved viagra
Pingback: cbd pills for sale
Pingback: buy cbd oil for cancer treatment
Pingback: cheapest online viagra
Pingback: pure cbd oil for pain
Pingback: can i buy viagra in china
Pingback: 200 mg sildenafil
Pingback: miracle cbd oil for sale amazon
Pingback: female viagra pills australia
Pingback: cbd oil in ohio
Pingback: buy viagra canada
Pingback: best cbd oil on amazon
Pingback: benefits of cbd oil for cancer patients
Pingback: australia viagra cost
Pingback: CANADA EN CARGO
Pingback: australian essay writing service
Pingback: buy viagra 25mg
Pingback: write an essay
Pingback: buying essays
Pingback: wake county schools assignment
Pingback: college paper writers
Pingback: generic viagra online 25mg
Pingback: essay paper writing services
Pingback: mymathlab answers to homework
Pingback: Buy Morphine pills online
Pingback: buy college essays
Pingback: admission essay writing services
Pingback: viagra 150mg
Pingback: cleocin 300mg without a prescription
Pingback: Cost viagra
Pingback: cheap clozaril 50 mg
Pingback: colchicine without prescription
Pingback: symbicort inhaler 160/4,5 mcg online pharmacy
Pingback: Viagra overnight
Pingback: coreg 25mg without prescription
Pingback: generic cialis
Pingback: compazine 5 mg without a doctor prescription
Pingback: EBAY
Pingback: coumadin without prescription
Pingback: buying viagra in mexico
Pingback: cozaar 100 mg coupon
Pingback: cheap crestor
Pingback: Buy shatter online
Pingback: cost of cymbalta 30mg
Pingback: help me write a thesis statement
Pingback: phd online
Pingback: dapsone 1000caps price
Pingback: ORDER LAB POWDERS WITHOUT RX
Pingback: order ddavp
Pingback: depakote 500mg tablets
Pingback: diamox medication
Pingback: how to achieve orgasm using a dildo for women
Pingback: differin 15g usa
Pingback: 우리카지노
Pingback: diltiazem pills
Pingback: 퍼스트카지노
Pingback: where can i buy doxycycline 100 mg
Pingback: cost of dramamine
Pingback: elavil united states
Pingback: cost of erythromycin
Pingback: etodolac 200 mg otc
Pingback: flomax 0,2mg otc
Pingback: flonase nasal spray nz
Pingback: WHERE TO BUY OPANA 40 MG ONLINE
Pingback: garcinia cambogia caps cost
Pingback: hyzaar united states
Pingback: cheapest imdur
Pingback: imitrex over the counter
Pingback: imodium pills
Pingback: read
Pingback: 샌즈카지노
Pingback: 메리트카지노
Pingback: where can i buy imuran
Pingback: lamisil online
Pingback: magic mushroom spores for sale
Pingback: 코인카지노
Pingback: детские аудио книги слушать
Pingback: Buy oxycodone online
Pingback: order lopid 300mg
Pingback: lopressor medication
Pingback: luvox 50mg cheap
Pingback: macrobid prices
Pingback: viagra online pharmacy
Pingback: Private detectives spain
Pingback: how to purchase mestinon 60 mg
Pingback: Detectives madrid
Pingback: Gorilla Glue Strain
Pingback: micardis otc
Pingback: pain meds online without doctor prescription
Pingback: cheapest mobic 15 mg
Pingback: Angela White Porn
Pingback: motrin 600 mg pharmacy
Pingback: viagra q and a
Pingback: nortriptyline 25 mg without a prescription
Pingback: periactin price
Pingback: how to purchase phenergan
Pingback: Microblading
Pingback: custom gift printing
Pingback: where can i buy plaquenil 200mg
Pingback: prednisolone 5mg without a doctor prescription
Pingback: Mink Eyelashes Set
Pingback: Soft Faux Mink Individual Lashes
Pingback: Professional Make up Tool Set
Pingback: Waterproof Silicone Face Cleansing Brush
Pingback: Reusable Natural 3D Mink Eyelashes
Pingback: prevacid no prescription
Pingback: Professional Makeup Brushes
Pingback: Champagne Makeup Brushes Set
Pingback: 3D Natural Soft Mink Eyelashes 10 set
Pingback: Waterproof Strong Eyelash Glue
Pingback: Nail Polish Remover Cotton Wipes Set
Pingback: cheap prilosec 10mg
Pingback: Professional Ceramic Hair Curler
Pingback: 3D Mink Magnetic Eyelashes with Eyeliner Kit
Pingback: Nail Art Dotting Pens Set
Pingback: 3D Faux Eyelashes Set
Pingback: proair inhaler no prescription
Pingback: procardia 30mg usa
Pingback: proscar no prescription
Pingback: protonix 20mg pills
Pingback: viagra soft
Pingback: provigil purchase
Pingback: Velvet Waterproof Lipstick 5 Pcs Set
Pingback: Flower Water Nail Stickers
Pingback: UV LED Nail Gel
Pingback: Anti Aging Face Steamer
Pingback: Disposable Eyelash Brushes Set
Pingback: Goat Hair Eye Makeup Brushes Set
Pingback: Waterproof Shimmer Lipstick
Pingback: Pearls Hairband for Women
Pingback: Gradient Color Nail Art Brush
Pingback: Set of 50 Metal Alligator Hair Clips
Pingback: pyridium generic
Pingback: Y Shaped Facial Massage Roller
Pingback: reglan australia
Pingback: Eyelash Brushes Disposable
Pingback: Crystal Nail Art Brushes
Pingback: remeron 15mg australia
Pingback: retin-a cream 0.025% tablet
Pingback: revatio 20mg generic
Pingback: risperdal united kingdom
Pingback: robaxin 500mg australia
Pingback: rogaine over the counter
Pingback: seroquel 50 mg tablets
Pingback: singulair 10 mg without a prescription
Pingback: order skelaxin 400mg
Pingback: tenormin no prescription
Pingback: thorazine cheap
Pingback: toprol medication
Pingback: tricor without prescription
Pingback: valtrex 500mg pharmacy
Pingback: vantin without prescription
Pingback: cost of verapamil 120 mg
Pingback: voltaren generic
Pingback: wellbutrin 300mg prices
Pingback: when can i buy generic cialis
Pingback: cost of zanaflex 2 mg
Pingback: zestril 5mg pharmacy
Pingback: order zithromax
Pingback: navigate to these guys
Pingback: zocor 5mg usa
Pingback: how to purchase zovirax 200mg
Pingback: zyloprim united kingdom
Pingback: viagra no prescription paypal
Pingback: zyvox 600mg without a doctor prescription
Pingback: sildenafil tablet
Pingback: buy tadalafil 80mg
Pingback: furosemide 40mg australia
Pingback: escitalopram online
Pingback: aripiprazole coupon
Pingback: nytimes
Pingback: pioglitazone 15 mg for sale
Pingback: norwaytoday
Pingback: spironolactone for sale
Pingback: fexofenadine uk
Pingback: glimepiride pills
Pingback: meclizine australia
Pingback: cheap leflunomide
Pingback: atomoxetine 40mg united kingdom
Pingback: dutchnews
Pingback: donepezil 5mg for sale
Pingback: anastrozole 1 mg cost
Pingback: irbesartan 300mg coupon
Pingback: cphpost
Pingback: dutasteride 0,5 mg without prescription
Pingback: olmesartan 40mg australia
Pingback: buspirone generic
Pingback: aftonbladet
Pingback: clonidine 0.1mg generic
Pingback: cefuroxime 500mg without prescription
Pingback: celecoxib 200mg generic
Pingback: where can i buy citalopram 10mg
Pingback: cephalexin over the counter
Pingback: spiegel
Pingback: ciprofloxacin canada
Pingback: postimees
Pingback: where can i buy clindamycin
Pingback: clozapine 50mg canada
Pingback: can you safely buy viagra online
Pingback: gayhub
Pingback: where to buy prochlorperazine
Pingback: helsinkitimes
Pingback: 1xbet android
Pingback: carvedilol prices
Pingback: remote control dildo
Pingback: anal numbing gel
Pingback: icelandreview
Pingback: warfarin no prescription
Pingback: thesouthafrican
Pingback: rosuvastatin 20mg over the counter
Pingback: مباراة اليوم
Pingback: desmopressin online
Pingback: اغانى شعبى
Pingback: best g spot vibrator
Pingback: Japanese Porn
Pingback: TransHub
Pingback: divalproex 250 mg online
Pingback: trazodone without a prescription
Pingback: where to buy tolterodine
Pingback: Buy percocet Online
Pingback: acetazolamide 250mg uk
Pingback: how to purchase fluconazole 100mg
Pingback: phenytoin 100mg couponcost of phenytoin
Pingback: oxybutynin over the counter
Pingback: doxycycline nz
Pingback: where to buy bisacodyl 5mg
Pingback: is there a generic drug for viagra
Pingback: venlafaxinemg online
Pingback: Cavachon puppies for sale
Pingback: GayHub
Pingback: pinball machines for sale
Pingback: amitriptyline 25 mg nz
Pingback: autoflowering blueberry seeds for sale
Pingback: permethrin online pharmacy
Pingback: how often can you take cialis
Pingback: Mining
Pingback: Mining
Pingback: erythromycin for sale
Pingback: estradiol otc
Pingback: MILF Porn
Pingback: cheap etodolac 400 mg
Pingback: Mountain bike clothing
Pingback: utuwjzok
Pingback: fluticasone mcg pharmacy
Pingback: how to get rid of viagra side effects
Pingback: kratom for sale
Pingback: how much is viagra at chemist warehouse
Pingback: sildenafil wanneer innemen
Pingback: hoe lang duurt het voor viagra werkt
Pingback: nitrofurantoin 100 mg uk
Pingback: where to buy ivermectin
Pingback: azithromycin what is it
Pingback: best over the counter viagra
Pingback: Trayal
Pingback: singapore loan broker
Pingback: HARDCORE OG DANK VAPES
Pingback: 샌즈카지노
Pingback: 우리카지노
Pingback: 메리트카지노
Pingback: 퍼스트카지노
Pingback: Dank Vapes
Pingback: isosorbide over the counter
Pingback: how to buy sumatriptan 25 mg
Pingback: check out canada immigration news
Pingback: AnaGlobal
Pingback: best cbd oil
Pingback: comprar cialis
Pingback: cialis without a prescription
Pingback: best cbd gummies
Pingback: viagra 100
Pingback: best cbd for dogs
Pingback: best cbd gummies
Pingback: sex as exercise calories
Pingback: cat shelters near me
Pingback: apartments for rent in singapore
Pingback: red maeng da kratom
Pingback: best prostate vibrator
Pingback: green maeng da kratom
Pingback: propranolol canada
Pingback: comprar viagra
Pingback: viagra email sent from my account
Pingback: working visa
Pingback: buy instagram followers
Pingback: 코인카지노
Pingback: cbd for sale
Pingback: assignment writing service uk
Pingback: how to write a research thesis
Pingback: virtual card buy for online shopping
Pingback: writing essay my holiday
Pingback: help me essay
Pingback: business ethics essay
Pingback: 레플리카 쇼핑몰
Pingback: Alpine Star Strain
Pingback: مزاداتي الجزائر
Pingback: best way to masturbate
Pingback: adam and eve vibrators
Pingback: 4-AcO DMT For Sale
Pingback: Minnesota Fake driver's license
Pingback: Gay Porn
Pingback: Can I buy Methadone online
Pingback: buy kratom online
Pingback: kratom for sleep
Pingback: lamotrigine usa
Pingback: level 3 credit card processing
Pingback: best clit tickler
Pingback: terbinafine 250 mg purchase