Turkey and the EU: Arms Trade Friends or Foes?

By: Dr. An Vranckx, Expert Analyst and Adviser, Catalystas Consulting and Aviva Stein, Strategy and Development Consultant, Catalystas Consulting

There is little as confusing in the world of international relations as the issue of moving weapons across borders. Following the aftermath of the 2016 failed coup in Turkey and the subsequent crackdown by the Turkish state on the predominantly Kurdish cities in the south, Dutch NGO Pax released a report regarding Turkey’s expanding military industry. The report recommended that EU countries restrain their arms transfers to Turkey, especially to its land and air forces, until progress towards a political solution with the Kurds could be made. Yet, the Consolidated Report on all EU countries’ exports of military goods and technologies shows that EU country exports to Turkey have actually increased, compared to prior years. Values reached nearly €3 billion worth of export licenses over 2017, with Bulgaria, France, Germany, Italy, and the UK all authorizing millions worth of export licenses for military goods destined to Turkey. The value of military sales from EU countries could have been even higher, if their strategic export control authorities had not refused 16 requests for export licenses to Turkey – a demonstration of caution which would likely have been unheard of prior to the coup attempt.

Though the EU is an economic union, in which all states honor a collectively agreed upon system of approving or denying trade partners and contracts based on a delineated set of 8 criteria, economic decisions do not happen in a vacuum. In the framework of the 2008 EU Common Position on military trade, to which all EU countries adhere, each country’s national export control authorities decide on exports to non-EU countries on a case-by-case basis. In cases such as arms trade deals with Turkey, geopolitical and military influences must also be considered as key factors in these export decisions. As a ‘safe’ ally and member of NATO, Turkey has rarely been denied the opportunity to buy and import military goods or technologies from EU countries. The US influence over NATO also sways these export decisions towards serving foreign policy and military priorities rather than solely economic incentives. However, some EU nations are more cautious than others, with the notable example of the Netherlands’ refusal to sell aircrafts to Turkey – although military naval equipment is still permitted.

Of the criteria spelled out in the EU Common Position, only one leads to a mandatory prohibition on export authorization: the obligation to adhere to embargoes set by international authorities, such as the UN Security Council or the EU’s own Council. This adherence to embargoes has resulted in hindering some arms trade, such as in the demise of a French business opportunity to build two Mistral warships for sale to Russia – a particularly sensitive deal as Russia would have acquired not only the ships, but also the technology needed for producing additional vessels internally. After the Russian annexation of the Crimea, a retaliatory European embargo was put in place to prevent delivering goods to Russia, leading to the retraction of the French-Russian deal, though France renewed the deal with Egypt two years later. The sanctions against Russia have continued, with the EU’s leading members calling for their enforcement until progress has been made towards a peaceful solution between Russia and the Ukraine. However, in October 2018, Italy’s Deputy Prime Minister noted the hypocrisy in disciplining Russia while taking no action against Turkey, which has occupied northern Cyprus since 1974.

No embargo is in place that forces EU countries’ arms export control authorities to effectively ‘blacklist’ Turkey. Once an eager applicant for EU membership, Turkey’s ongoing and recent actions call into question its commitment to peaceful coexistence and human rights. The Turkish state has used military gear procured from EU countries in ways that now embarrass its suppliers. German-designed Leopard tanks have been deployed against the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), the local allies of the Global Coalition Against ISIS in northeastern Syria; a batch of French-sold sorbitol, which can be used as rocket propellant, ended up in the hands of ISIS after vanishing from Turkey in 2015. As a whole, the current state of arms transfers between EU countries and Turkey paints a grim picture for the future of adherence to international norms and respect for human rights. Perhaps it is time to follow the advice of PAX, and support the sale of peace, rather than war.

Cover pic: Shutterstock.com

470 comments

  1. Pingback: cialis price

  2. Pingback: is cialis generic

  3. Pingback: cheap cialis

  4. Pingback: viagra for sale

  5. Pingback: tadalafil online pharmacy

  6. Pingback: buy ciprofloxacin online

  7. Pingback: albuterol inhaler

  8. Pingback: viagra without a doctor prescription

  9. Pingback: naltrexone price 50mg

  10. Pingback: generic cialis online

  11. Pingback: generic tylenol at walmart

  12. Pingback: chloroquine tablet 500mg

  13. Pingback: uk viagra

  14. Pingback: can i buy chloroquine over the counter

  15. Pingback: ed drugs

  16. Pingback: erectile dysfunction pills

  17. Pingback: male ed pills

  18. Pingback: hydroxychloroquine uk pharmacy

  19. Pingback: buy generic cialis

  20. Pingback: canadian online pharmacy

  21. Pingback: online pharmacy

  22. Pingback: Buy cialis online

  23. Pingback: cialis visa

  24. Pingback: levitra dosage

  25. Pingback: generic levitra

  26. Pingback: cialis 20mg dosage

  27. Pingback: wind creek casino online games

  28. Pingback: sildenafil online

  29. Pingback: hollywood casino online real money

  30. Pingback: best online casinos that payout

  31. Pingback: generic viagra 20mg pills erections

  32. Pingback: buy cialis pills

  33. Pingback: cash payday

  34. Pingback: pay day loans

  35. Pingback: viagra 100mg

  36. Pingback: best real money online casinos

  37. Pingback: best slots to play online

  38. Pingback: estelle

  39. Pingback: empire casino online

  40. Pingback: casino that accept paypal

  41. Pingback: generic cialis

  42. Pingback: order viagra without prescription

  43. Pingback: cialis generic

  44. Pingback: cialis 5 mg

  45. Pingback: generic cialis

  46. Pingback: buy hydroxychloroquine online

  47. Pingback: online casino

  48. Pingback: casino gambling

  49. Pingback: real money online casinos usa

  50. Pingback: casinos

  51. Pingback: viagra prescription

  52. Pingback: viagra online canadian pharmacy

  53. Pingback: viagra dosage

  54. Pingback: buy generic cialis online

  55. Pingback: buy generic cialis online

  56. Pingback: cheap cialis

  57. Pingback: generic cialis online

  58. Pingback: casino games online

  59. Pingback: best online casino real money

  60. Pingback: cheap viagra online

  61. Pingback: sildenafil citrate generic viagra

  62. Pingback: Google

  63. Pingback: free app for windows 8 download

  64. Pingback: health insurance broker

  65. Pingback: Employee health insurance plans

  66. Pingback: health insurance broker

  67. Pingback: aquatherapie für hund

  68. Pingback: russian literature classics

  69. Pingback: most realistic dildos

  70. Pingback: gamdom

  71. Pingback: wolfbet

  72. Pingback: Kenyatta

  73. Pingback: buy cialis online without prescription

  74. Pingback: Loans

  75. Pingback: Mastercard Corporate Credit Card

  76. Pingback: Viagra 100mg prices

  77. Pingback: furnace service colorado springs

  78. Pingback: Cialis 80 mg online pharmacy

  79. Pingback: christian seo

  80. Pingback: computer disposal companies london

  81. Pingback: pubg mobile emülatör hile

  82. Pingback: Teacup Pomeranian Puppies for Sale

  83. Pingback: Puppies for adoption near me

  84. Pingback: THC VAPE JUICE

  85. Pingback: dinh cu canada

  86. Pingback: canadian pharmacy

  87. Pingback: rodos feribot

  88. Pingback: viagra generique livre sous 48h

  89. Pingback: ampicillin 500mg without a prescription

  90. Pingback: mua hat macca o tphcm

  91. Pingback: sweetiehouse

  92. Pingback: cialistodo.com

  93. Pingback: beginner sex toys

  94. Pingback: blogcaodep.com

  95. Pingback: computers

  96. Pingback: cost of augmentin 875/125mg

  97. Pingback: Damiana

  98. Pingback: High Efficiency Irrigation System

  99. Pingback: Gerüstbau

  100. Pingback: havuz market

  101. Pingback: sývý klor

  102. Pingback: sweetiehouse.vn

  103. Pingback: red nose pitbull puppies for sale

  104. Pingback: Shotguns for sale

  105. Pingback: Buy heroin online

  106. Pingback: Pc hilfe wolfhausen

  107. Pingback: Glock 33

  108. Pingback: fluffy kittens for sale

  109. Pingback: FAKE MONEY FOR SALE ONLINE

  110. Pingback: Pomsky Puppies For Sale Near me

  111. Pingback: buy viagra online

  112. Pingback: catapres over the counter

  113. Pingback: sex hard

  114. Pingback: how to buy ceclor

  115. Pingback: where can i buy ceftin 250mg

  116. Pingback: hat hanh nhan an song duoc khong

  117. Pingback: celebrex 200 mg otc

  118. Pingback: thc vape juice

  119. Pingback: celexa otc

  120. Pingback: virtual credit card buy

  121. Pingback: cephalexin 500 mg tablet

  122. Pingback: comfortis without vet prescription

  123. Pingback: cipro 750mg for sale

  124. Pingback: claritin 10 mg over the counter

  125. Pingback: Halkbank İnternet Şubesi Şifre Alma

  126. Pingback: generic viagra

  127. Pingback: best slots to play online

  128. Pingback: ziraat kart şifresi alma

  129. Pingback: golden nugget online casino

  130. Pingback: slot games online

  131. Pingback: Muha Meds Blue Dream 1000mg

  132. Pingback: online casinos

  133. Pingback: wind creek casino online games

  134. Pingback: Naturkosmetik

  135. Pingback: san manuel casino online

  136. Pingback: best online casino for money

  137. Pingback: online casino games for real money

  138. Pingback: generic ed pills

  139. Pingback: real online casino

  140. Pingback: sr22 insurance

  141. Pingback: triple a car insurance

  142. Pingback: HRDF Google Marketing

  143. Pingback: list of car insurance quotes companies

  144. Pingback: Tenuate retard

  145. Pingback: counties viagra is legal

  146. Pingback: 1000mg thc vape juice

  147. Pingback: car insurance quotes in nj

  148. Pingback: Fish scale cocaine

  149. Pingback: nationwide insurance

  150. Pingback: Undergraduate Kenya

  151. Pingback: k2 spray on paper

  152. Pingback: Buy Methadone 10mg online

  153. Pingback: car insurance coverage

  154. Pingback: direct line car insurance quotes

  155. Pingback: american car insurance quotes

  156. Pingback: brazzers

  157. Pingback: payday loans wisconsin

  158. Pingback: leavers t-shirts.

  159. Pingback: installment loans rock hill sc

  160. Pingback: buy viagra online with paypal

  161. Pingback: usa pharmacy

  162. Pingback: payday

  163. Pingback: small payday loans for bad credit

  164. Pingback: personal loans companies

  165. Pingback: Fda approved viagra

  166. Pingback: cbd pills for sale

  167. Pingback: buy cbd oil for cancer treatment

  168. Pingback: cheapest online viagra

  169. Pingback: pure cbd oil for pain

  170. Pingback: can i buy viagra in china

  171. Pingback: 200 mg sildenafil

  172. Pingback: miracle cbd oil for sale amazon

  173. Pingback: female viagra pills australia

  174. Pingback: cbd oil in ohio

  175. Pingback: buy viagra canada

  176. Pingback: best cbd oil on amazon

  177. Pingback: benefits of cbd oil for cancer patients

  178. Pingback: australia viagra cost

  179. Pingback: CANADA EN CARGO

  180. Pingback: australian essay writing service

  181. Pingback: buy viagra 25mg

  182. Pingback: write an essay

  183. Pingback: buying essays

  184. Pingback: wake county schools assignment

  185. Pingback: college paper writers

  186. Pingback: generic viagra online 25mg

  187. Pingback: essay paper writing services

  188. Pingback: mymathlab answers to homework

  189. Pingback: Buy Morphine pills online

  190. Pingback: buy college essays

  191. Pingback: admission essay writing services

  192. Pingback: viagra 150mg

  193. Pingback: cleocin 300mg without a prescription

  194. Pingback: Cost viagra

  195. Pingback: cheap clozaril 50 mg

  196. Pingback: colchicine without prescription

  197. Pingback: symbicort inhaler 160/4,5 mcg online pharmacy

  198. Pingback: Viagra overnight

  199. Pingback: coreg 25mg without prescription

  200. Pingback: generic cialis

  201. Pingback: compazine 5 mg without a doctor prescription

  202. Pingback: EBAY

  203. Pingback: coumadin without prescription

  204. Pingback: buying viagra in mexico

  205. Pingback: cozaar 100 mg coupon

  206. Pingback: cheap crestor

  207. Pingback: Buy shatter online

  208. Pingback: cost of cymbalta 30mg

  209. Pingback: help me write a thesis statement

  210. Pingback: phd online

  211. Pingback: dapsone 1000caps price

  212. Pingback: ORDER LAB POWDERS WITHOUT RX

  213. Pingback: order ddavp

  214. Pingback: depakote 500mg tablets

  215. Pingback: diamox medication

  216. Pingback: how to achieve orgasm using a dildo for women

  217. Pingback: differin 15g usa

  218. Pingback: 우리카지노

  219. Pingback: diltiazem pills

  220. Pingback: 퍼스트카지노

  221. Pingback: where can i buy doxycycline 100 mg

  222. Pingback: cost of dramamine

  223. Pingback: elavil united states

  224. Pingback: cost of erythromycin

  225. Pingback: etodolac 200 mg otc

  226. Pingback: flomax 0,2mg otc

  227. Pingback: flonase nasal spray nz

  228. Pingback: WHERE TO BUY OPANA 40 MG ONLINE

  229. Pingback: garcinia cambogia caps cost

  230. Pingback: hyzaar united states

  231. Pingback: cheapest imdur

  232. Pingback: imitrex over the counter

  233. Pingback: imodium pills

  234. Pingback: read

  235. Pingback: 샌즈카지노

  236. Pingback: 메리트카지노

  237. Pingback: where can i buy imuran

  238. Pingback: lamisil online

  239. Pingback: magic mushroom spores for sale

  240. Pingback: 코인카지노

  241. Pingback: детские аудио книги слушать

  242. Pingback: Buy oxycodone online

  243. Pingback: order lopid 300mg

  244. Pingback: lopressor medication

  245. Pingback: luvox 50mg cheap

  246. Pingback: macrobid prices

  247. Pingback: viagra online pharmacy

  248. Pingback: Private detectives spain

  249. Pingback: how to purchase mestinon 60 mg

  250. Pingback: Detectives madrid

  251. Pingback: Gorilla Glue Strain

  252. Pingback: micardis otc

  253. Pingback: pain meds online without doctor prescription

  254. Pingback: cheapest mobic 15 mg

  255. Pingback: Angela White Porn

  256. Pingback: motrin 600 mg pharmacy

  257. Pingback: viagra q and a

  258. Pingback: nortriptyline 25 mg without a prescription

  259. Pingback: periactin price

  260. Pingback: how to purchase phenergan

  261. Pingback: Microblading

  262. Pingback: custom gift printing

  263. Pingback: where can i buy plaquenil 200mg

  264. Pingback: prednisolone 5mg without a doctor prescription

  265. Pingback: Mink Eyelashes Set

  266. Pingback: Soft Faux Mink Individual Lashes

  267. Pingback: Professional Make up Tool Set

  268. Pingback: Waterproof Silicone Face Cleansing Brush

  269. Pingback: Reusable Natural 3D Mink Eyelashes

  270. Pingback: prevacid no prescription

  271. Pingback: Professional Makeup Brushes

  272. Pingback: Champagne Makeup Brushes Set

  273. Pingback: 3D Natural Soft Mink Eyelashes 10 set

  274. Pingback: Waterproof Strong Eyelash Glue

  275. Pingback: Nail Polish Remover Cotton Wipes Set

  276. Pingback: cheap prilosec 10mg

  277. Pingback: Professional Ceramic Hair Curler

  278. Pingback: 3D Mink Magnetic Eyelashes with Eyeliner Kit

  279. Pingback: Nail Art Dotting Pens Set

  280. Pingback: 3D Faux Eyelashes Set

  281. Pingback: proair inhaler no prescription

  282. Pingback: procardia 30mg usa

  283. Pingback: proscar no prescription

  284. Pingback: protonix 20mg pills

  285. Pingback: viagra soft

  286. Pingback: provigil purchase

  287. Pingback: Velvet Waterproof Lipstick 5 Pcs Set

  288. Pingback: Flower Water Nail Stickers

  289. Pingback: UV LED Nail Gel

  290. Pingback: Anti Aging Face Steamer

  291. Pingback: Disposable Eyelash Brushes Set

  292. Pingback: Goat Hair Eye Makeup Brushes Set

  293. Pingback: Waterproof Shimmer Lipstick

  294. Pingback: Pearls Hairband for Women

  295. Pingback: Gradient Color Nail Art Brush

  296. Pingback: Set of 50 Metal Alligator Hair Clips

  297. Pingback: pyridium generic

  298. Pingback: Y Shaped Facial Massage Roller

  299. Pingback: reglan australia

  300. Pingback: Eyelash Brushes Disposable

  301. Pingback: Crystal Nail Art Brushes

  302. Pingback: remeron 15mg australia

  303. Pingback: retin-a cream 0.025% tablet

  304. Pingback: revatio 20mg generic

  305. Pingback: risperdal united kingdom

  306. Pingback: robaxin 500mg australia

  307. Pingback: rogaine over the counter

  308. Pingback: seroquel 50 mg tablets

  309. Pingback: singulair 10 mg without a prescription

  310. Pingback: order skelaxin 400mg

  311. Pingback: tenormin no prescription

  312. Pingback: thorazine cheap

  313. Pingback: toprol medication

  314. Pingback: tricor without prescription

  315. Pingback: valtrex 500mg pharmacy

  316. Pingback: vantin without prescription

  317. Pingback: cost of verapamil 120 mg

  318. Pingback: voltaren generic

  319. Pingback: wellbutrin 300mg prices

  320. Pingback: when can i buy generic cialis

  321. Pingback: cost of zanaflex 2 mg

  322. Pingback: zestril 5mg pharmacy

  323. Pingback: order zithromax

  324. Pingback: navigate to these guys

  325. Pingback: zocor 5mg usa

  326. Pingback: how to purchase zovirax 200mg

  327. Pingback: zyloprim united kingdom

  328. Pingback: viagra no prescription paypal

  329. Pingback: zyvox 600mg without a doctor prescription

  330. Pingback: sildenafil tablet

  331. Pingback: buy tadalafil 80mg

  332. Pingback: furosemide 40mg australia

  333. Pingback: escitalopram online

  334. Pingback: aripiprazole coupon

  335. Pingback: nytimes

  336. Pingback: pioglitazone 15 mg for sale

  337. Pingback: norwaytoday

  338. Pingback: spironolactone for sale

  339. Pingback: fexofenadine uk

  340. Pingback: glimepiride pills

  341. Pingback: meclizine australia

  342. Pingback: cheap leflunomide

  343. Pingback: atomoxetine 40mg united kingdom

  344. Pingback: dutchnews

  345. Pingback: donepezil 5mg for sale

  346. Pingback: anastrozole 1 mg cost

  347. Pingback: irbesartan 300mg coupon

  348. Pingback: cphpost

  349. Pingback: dutasteride 0,5 mg without prescription

  350. Pingback: olmesartan 40mg australia

  351. Pingback: buspirone generic

  352. Pingback: aftonbladet

  353. Pingback: clonidine 0.1mg generic

  354. Pingback: cefuroxime 500mg without prescription

  355. Pingback: celecoxib 200mg generic

  356. Pingback: where can i buy citalopram 10mg

  357. Pingback: cephalexin over the counter

  358. Pingback: spiegel

  359. Pingback: ciprofloxacin canada

  360. Pingback: postimees

  361. Pingback: where can i buy clindamycin

  362. Pingback: clozapine 50mg canada

  363. Pingback: can you safely buy viagra online

  364. Pingback: gayhub

  365. Pingback: where to buy prochlorperazine

  366. Pingback: helsinkitimes

  367. Pingback: 1xbet android

  368. Pingback: carvedilol prices

  369. Pingback: remote control dildo

  370. Pingback: anal numbing gel

  371. Pingback: icelandreview

  372. Pingback: warfarin no prescription

  373. Pingback: thesouthafrican

  374. Pingback: rosuvastatin 20mg over the counter

  375. Pingback: مباراة اليوم

  376. Pingback: desmopressin online

  377. Pingback: اغانى شعبى

  378. Pingback: best g spot vibrator

  379. Pingback: Japanese Porn

  380. Pingback: TransHub

  381. Pingback: divalproex 250 mg online

  382. Pingback: trazodone without a prescription

  383. Pingback: where to buy tolterodine

  384. Pingback: Buy percocet Online

  385. Pingback: acetazolamide 250mg uk

  386. Pingback: how to purchase fluconazole 100mg

  387. Pingback: phenytoin 100mg couponcost of phenytoin

  388. Pingback: oxybutynin over the counter

  389. Pingback: doxycycline nz

  390. Pingback: where to buy bisacodyl 5mg

  391. Pingback: is there a generic drug for viagra

  392. Pingback: venlafaxinemg online

  393. Pingback: Cavachon puppies for sale

  394. Pingback: GayHub

  395. Pingback: pinball machines for sale

  396. Pingback: amitriptyline 25 mg nz

  397. Pingback: autoflowering blueberry seeds for sale

  398. Pingback: permethrin online pharmacy

  399. Pingback: how often can you take cialis

  400. Pingback: Mining

  401. Pingback: Mining

  402. Pingback: erythromycin for sale

  403. Pingback: estradiol otc

  404. Pingback: MILF Porn

  405. Pingback: cheap etodolac 400 mg

  406. Pingback: Mountain bike clothing

  407. Pingback: utuwjzok

  408. Pingback: fluticasone mcg pharmacy

  409. Pingback: how to get rid of viagra side effects

  410. Pingback: kratom for sale

  411. Pingback: how much is viagra at chemist warehouse

  412. Pingback: sildenafil wanneer innemen

  413. Pingback: hoe lang duurt het voor viagra werkt

  414. Pingback: nitrofurantoin 100 mg uk

  415. Pingback: where to buy ivermectin

  416. Pingback: azithromycin what is it

  417. Pingback: best over the counter viagra

  418. Pingback: Trayal

  419. Pingback: singapore loan broker

  420. Pingback: HARDCORE OG DANK VAPES

  421. Pingback: 샌즈카지노

  422. Pingback: 우리카지노

  423. Pingback: 메리트카지노

  424. Pingback: 퍼스트카지노

  425. Pingback: Dank Vapes

  426. Pingback: isosorbide over the counter

  427. Pingback: how to buy sumatriptan 25 mg

  428. Pingback: check out canada immigration news

  429. Pingback: AnaGlobal

  430. Pingback: best cbd oil

  431. Pingback: comprar cialis

  432. Pingback: cialis without a prescription

  433. Pingback: best cbd gummies

  434. Pingback: viagra 100

  435. Pingback: best cbd for dogs

  436. Pingback: best cbd gummies

  437. Pingback: sex as exercise calories

  438. Pingback: cat shelters near me

  439. Pingback: apartments for rent in singapore

  440. Pingback: red maeng da kratom

  441. Pingback: best prostate vibrator

  442. Pingback: green maeng da kratom

  443. Pingback: propranolol canada

  444. Pingback: comprar viagra

  445. Pingback: viagra email sent from my account

  446. Pingback: working visa

  447. Pingback: buy instagram followers

  448. Pingback: 코인카지노

  449. Pingback: cbd for sale

  450. Pingback: assignment writing service uk

  451. Pingback: how to write a research thesis

  452. Pingback: virtual card buy for online shopping

  453. Pingback: writing essay my holiday

  454. Pingback: help me essay

  455. Pingback: business ethics essay

  456. Pingback: 레플리카 쇼핑몰

  457. Pingback: Alpine Star Strain

  458. Pingback: مزاداتي الجزائر

  459. Pingback: best way to masturbate

  460. Pingback: adam and eve vibrators

  461. Pingback: 4-AcO DMT For Sale

  462. Pingback: Minnesota Fake driver's license

  463. Pingback: Gay Porn

  464. Pingback: Can I buy Methadone online

  465. Pingback: buy kratom online

  466. Pingback: kratom for sleep

  467. Pingback: lamotrigine usa

  468. Pingback: level 3 credit card processing

  469. Pingback: best clit tickler

  470. Pingback: terbinafine 250 mg purchase